Unanswered Questions About Gay Marriage

Please tell me.

A bill to fully recognize same-sex marriage in the State of New Jersey was once again introduced. Many legislators who voted against a like bill in 2010 have said that they would turn their votes about and vote in favor of passage this time around. We have a governor who has stated he will not sign such a bill should it come to his desk. And the beat goes on…

Of the people I speak to now, just as in 2010, those who are in favor of passage of this bill are vehemently so and those opposed likewise. Can’t say that I have run into anyone who has no opinion at all. For those in opposition I will always ask, “So why are you so adamantly against same-sex marriage?” Almost to a person they will reply with a question, “Well, what does that say about my marriage or the institution of marriage if gays are allowed to marry?”

To this I counter, “Okay, what does it say about your marriage or the institution of marriage?” I am a pretty old duck and I have asked this question of many people over a good many years. The response has been, almost to a person, “Ah, well, I think, really…hm. Well if you can get married then my marriage…my marriage…ah…well then that means that the marriage of anyone is…ah, well – I don’t think it’s a good thing because…yadda, yadda, yadda.”

I have been told that legalizing gay marriage will make less of everyone else’s marriage. How so? A politician recently pontificating said that the legalizing of gay marriage would be an ‘abomination’. A noted archbishop very recently given the nod by the Vatican to enter the College of Cardinals said last year when asked about the possible approval of gay marriage in the State of New York, “God, not Albany, has settled the definition of marriage a long time ago.” This is not the church’s domain – we have separation of church and state in this country.  Like it or not – God didn’t get a vote in New York State. Ah, and the beat goes on…

The divorce rate in this country is at close to 50 percent in the heterosexual community. What exactly does that figure say about marriage in general? For the purist: what does the fact that many folks no longer feel a need to marry at all and just live together say? And, what say they about the still more couples worldwide who chose to have two or three kids before they finally marry. Do they make less of your marriage? Silly me, that’s different, of course, because they are one man and one woman. And the beat goes on…

I do not believe that any church, synagogue or other religious institution should be forced to marry within their faith anyone who they do not feel fits their qualifications. I don’t agree with this treatment but this is America and we have separation of church and state. What, who said that? 

There is no way to predict what will happen when this bill comes to a vote in New Jersey. I’ve heard of late that if the governor refuses to sign it, as he has promised to do, but lets it sit on his desk for 45 days then it can pass without his signature. I don’t think that will happen.

Still, lingering in the back of my mind is that question: ‘What does it say about your marriage or the institution of marriage?’ Are those of you who so fear legalizing of my right to marry concerned about the strength of your own union? Can you not rise to the occasion and make the life you share with another the epitome of marriage, a shining example of all that marriage can be? Can you not rejoice in my desire to meet the example you could set? It is so very sad - the example that the self-righteous set, so very sad. And the beat goes on…

C.M. McLoughlin, a writer and editor from New Jersey and New York, can be reached at mcloughlin43@gmail.com.

Christina Warren January 15, 2012 at 01:09 AM
Elliot please read my comment below
Christina Warren January 15, 2012 at 01:16 AM
I am not opposed to any person making their choice to date or marry whom they want. Please listen when I say, That I have a love for people not their sin. What you choose to believe is your choice, doesn't have to be mine. And I am not force feeding anyone anything. My choice, my right, my life, isn't that same thing homosexual couples are pleading for? Sounds like we all want the same thing.
Kristen Watkins February 09, 2012 at 11:57 PM
Hi. I know there has been confusion about exactly where God states that marriage cannot be between a man and a woman. The bible has recently been rewritten to better portray exactly what the original version had said, so it is very possible, very likely, that God's exact message was somewhat skewed. Would you tell us the exact excerpt from the bible that says that it can only be between a man and a woman and that it is a SIN for a man to marry another man? Also, u would need to speak latin an whatever other languages that were incorporated in the original bible in order to truly understand what God had meant. Also, as the article does state, the church is (supposedly) separate from the government. Therefore, it makes no sense that marriage cannot be LEGAL (a political word, am i wrong?) because God (a purely religious figure, yes?) says (and we do not even have clear proof of this) that it is wrong. A counter argument can be made that murder is against gods will and is also illegal; but murder harms other people. Two people who are in love marrying one another is in no way hurting someone else. Therefore, Gods apparent viewpoint should not even be taken into consideration when the LAW determines whether same-sex marriage should be legal. Thank you
Kristen Watkins February 09, 2012 at 11:57 PM
Barbara Ganim May 08, 2012 at 05:59 PM
Thank you for the intelligent responses to Christina's personally biased comments on what "God wants us to do." As she stated, this is the truth she follows. Please dear Christians, follow your faith and do honor your own truths and spiritual beliefs. But please treat others as you wish to be treated by allowing us the legal rights to follow our own truths and spiritual beliefs without your imposed restrictions. Christina you also say, "Let's face it, church and state have never truly been separated." That has always been at the heart of the civil rights problem. Civil rights are what the question of gay rights is all about. It is not about God, Christianity or any religious belief or approval. Even though Christians are strongly attempting to make it so. In this country, we have always fought the interference of the church to impose its beliefs on our legal rights. If we lose this fight for gay rights, we will come dangerously closer to being a country controlled by its clergy. We need only to look at Middle Eastern countries controlled by clergy to see how they exercise their "God Given Right" to not just suppress but destroy any one person or group, including other religious groups whose beliefs differ from their own. This country was founded on religious freedom, and the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. When we all have equal rights, including women who still do not have an Equal Rights Amendment, we will have a truly democratic country.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »